USPS must reform its measures to manage the rate reform
Cary H. BaerThere’s a saying in business that’s long been a truism: If you don’t measure, you can’t manage. Recent postal reform legislation had requirements for the US Postal Service to develop delivery service standards, and then to report on actual delivery service.
The mailing community has consistently called for the USPS to develop delivery service standards for all classes of mail and to report on adherence to those standards.
The USPS has been consistent in ignoring its customers’ calls for delivery service reportage. With reform legislation mandating delivery service reporting, the jig is up. So, the USPS — along with a broad-based mailers organization, Mailers Technical Advisory Committee — has been developing delivery service standards. These groups, with the Postal Regulatory Commission, will agree on delivery service standards. The industry eagerly awaits reports that will show actual delivery service performance.
There are two other measurement issues. First, is a measurement system called total factor productivity (TFP). The Postal Service regularly reports its productivity using TFP. Recently, a well respected member of the mailing community stated that, although he had long heard TFP statistics, he really didn’t understand them. It made me realize that I, too, could not explain TFP, so I went to the USPS Web site to get an understanding of it. The definition was, “TFP measures the growth in the ratio of outputs and the inputs, or resources, expended in producing those outputs.” The definition then says, “the Postal Service’s main outputs are mail volumes and servicing an expanding delivery network.”
The definition then gets complicated as it explains the various factors (i.e., adjustments) that must be made to compensate for mail type, size, weight, mailer preparation (barcoding, presorting), mode of transportation, capital usage, etc. The reality is that with so many adjustments, the TFP productivity statistic, while it may be accurate, is too complicated for laymen — or knowledgeable postal watchers — to understand.
With 80 percent of its expenses tied to labor, the key productivity statistic — indeed, perhaps the only one that matters — must simply relate mail volume to labor hours. Does mail mix or mailer preparation, size and weight matter? Sure. But in the end, mail volume and labor hours used to handle it, are all that matters. The USPS should use that as its key productivity statistic, and it’s what management should focus on.
Read More
