Year: 2005

Barriers to competition in the German and UK postal market

Report for Ministry of Economic Affairs, the Netherlands.
Table of contents
1 Introduction 9
1.1 Purpose and background of the study 9
1.2 Entry barriers in postal markets 9
1.3 Postal products and market segmentation 11
1.4 Activities undertaken and structure of the report 12
2 Barriers to competition: does de jure liberalisation lead to de facto
liberalisation? 13
2.1 Introduction 13
2.2 Assessment of potential barriers to competition 13
2.2.1 Time path for liberalisation 13
2.2.2 Licence requirements 14
2.2.3 Downstream access 15
2.2.4 Strategic behaviour of incumbents and position of postal regulator 17
2.2.5 VAT exemptions 18
3 Conclusion 25
3.1 Summary of main observations 25
3.2 Recommended course of action 26
Annex 1 How does a VAT work? 29
Annex 2 Barriers to competition in the UK postal market 33
1 Barriers to entry caused by the regulatory framework 35
1.1 General 35
1.2 Reserved area 35
1.3 Regulatory uncertainty: access to the final mile delivery network 36
1.4 Licence requirements and entry conditions 36
1.4.1 Operational procedures and traffic interchange 36
1.4.2 Licence applications and annual fees 37
1.4.3 Reserve funds 37
1.5 Tariff regulation 38
1.6 Competing operators 38
1.7 Exclusivity agreements 39
1.8 Access 39
1.9 Returned mail and misrouted mail 42
2 Strategic entry barriers 45
2.1 Cross-subsidies 45
2.2 Predatory pricing 45
2.3 Bundling and tying 46
2.4 Vertical foreclosure 46
2.5 Non-price barriers 46
2.5.1 The AMP investigation 47
3 Level playing field 49
3.1 VAT exemption 49
3.2 Immunity from parking penalties 49
3.3 Change in address notification 49
4 The universal service obligation and uniform pricing 51
5 Conclusions 53
5.1 Barriers to entry caused by the regulatory framework 53
5.2 Does Royal Mail have rights/facilities that are not strictly necessary for
servicing the USO, and do these rights/facilities lead to unequal
competition? 53
5.3 What are the practical barriers to entry or operation that might constitute an
unlevel playing field? 53
Annex 2A List of interview partners 55
Annex 3 Barriers to competition in the German postal market 57
1 Barriers to entry caused by the regulatory framework 59
1.1 General 59
1.2 Reserved area 59
1.3 Regulatory uncertainty: unconditional liberalisation 59
1.4 Licence requirements and entry conditions 60
1.5 Tariff regulation 60
1.6 Competing operators 60
1.7 Access 61
1.9 Returned mail and misrouted mail 62
2 Strategic entry barriers 63
2.1 Cross subsidisation and predatory pricing 63
2.2 Bundling and tying 63
2.3 Vertical foreclosure 63
2.4 Non price barriers 64
2.5 Mandate of the regulator 64
3 Level playing field 65
3.1 VAT exemption 65
3.2 Consolidation 65
3.3 Other issues 65
3.5 Change in address notifications 66
3.6 The universal service obligation and uniform pricing 66
4 Conclusion 67
4.1 Barriers to entry caused by the regulatory framework 67
Annex 3A List of interview partners 69
Annex 4 Barriers to competition in the Dutch postal market 71
1 Barriers to entry caused by the regulatory framework 73
1.1 General 73
1.2 Reserved area 73
1.3 Regulatory uncertainty: conditional liberalisation 74
1.4 Licence requirements and entry conditions 74
1.5 Tariff regulation 74
1.6 Competing operators 74
1.7 Access 75
1.9 Returned mail and misrouted mail 76
2 Strategic entry barriers 79
2.1 Cross-subsidies 79
2.2 Predatory pricing 79
2.3 Bundling and tying 79
2.4 Vertical foreclosure 79
2.5 Non-price barriers 80
2.6 Mandate of the regulator 80
3 Level playing field 83
3.1 VAT exemption 83
3.2 Release for driving through shopping areas 83
4 Conclusion 85
Annex 4B List of interview partners 87
Annex 5 List of participants of the workshop 89

P:LibraryPostalEcorys Barriers to competition in Germany & UK.pdf

Read More

Royal Mail pledge over post market competition

Royal Mail today vowed to “fight for every letter” following the New Year’s Day postal revolution in which it will lose its 350-year monopoly on deliveries.

The UK’s postal service market will be opened up on January 1, allowing rival companies to collect, sort and deliver mail for the first time since the reign of Charles II.

Royal Mail faces competition from 14 companies which have already registered with regulator Postcomm to handle post in the UK, including German firm Deutsche Post and Dutch postal service TNT.

Most of the competition is expected to be in business mail, which accounts for 80% of the market and helped boost Royal Mail profits by 20% to £159 million in the first half of 2005.

Read More

UK Royal Mail ‘needs GBP2bn to fight new competition’

Royal Mail said today that it needed to invest GBP2bn in modernisation as it braces itself for an onslaught of new competition from January 1. No less than 14 companies have registered with regulator Postcomm to handle post in the UK, including German firm Deutsche Post and Dutch postal service TNT. Royal Mail said it would “fight for every letter”, but stressed the importance of new investment. “Royal Mail will fight hard for every single letter. Royal Mail is determined to compete successfully in the open market – but in order to do so we need a fair regulatory regime and the ability to invest GBP2bn in the modernisation of the business,” Royal Mail spokesman David Simpson said.

Read More

Palletways in Denmark

Palletways, which claims to be Europe’s largest provider of express distribution services for small consignments of palletised freight, has appointed its first member in Denmark – Esbjerg-based IAT.

Read More

DHL, UPS eye business opportunities in China’s Qingdao

DHL has announced that it will launch cargo flights between Qingdao, east China’s Shandong Province, and Hong Kong via Hangzhou, in eastern Zhejiang Province, in February next year. Several months ago, another express giant UPS from the United States launched direct cargo flights between Qingdao and Inchon, the Republic of Korea. Ken Rorok, UPS Asia-Pacific regional president, said Qingdao, as a major harbor city, provides broader market opportunities.

Read More

Rivals snap at the heels of UK Royal Mail

Royal Mail expects to lose “billions” of mail items to its rivals over the next 12 months, following the opening up of the market to full competition on January 1. And in the change that will follow the New Year’s day revolution in the postal services market, it is business customers that are expected to be in the lead. Royal Mail lost its monopoly on mailings of 4,000 and more items in April 2003. Next week, the rest of the Pounds 6.5bn market, including lower volumes of mail sent by small businesses, is being opened up. Companies account for more than 80 per cent of the licensed market: mail costing less than Pounds 1 and weighing less than 350g. Royal Mail’s main competitors include TNT Mail, the UK arm of TPG, the Dutch postal group; DHL Global Mail, the UK arm of Deutsche Post, the German postal operator; and UK Mail, owned by Business Post, a quoted express delivery company. Those competitors say they intend to use the January 1 liberalisation as a catalyst to step up the pressure on the state-owned operator, using a combination of pricing and product innovation to try to woo more of its business customers.

Read More

Minister to talk with UK Royal Mail‘s Leighton after tough efficiency targets agreed

Ministers are to open talks with Royal Mail over its demands for up to Pounds 2bn of investment after the postal operator agreed to tough new targets for improving efficiency. The negotiations, which will run well into the new year, are expected to focus on several options, all of which would involve the government, which is the state-owned postal operator’s sole shareholder, putting public money into the company. With Royal Mail’s financial position precarious, and trade unions fearful of another round of job cuts, its management is lobbying the Department of Trade and Industry for help. One option under discussion would be to provide the company with a loan repayable over a number of years. Another option, favoured by Royal Mail, could be some form of equity investment, not unlike a rights issue, under which the government would inject cash as equity in return for a bigger dividend in future. Alan Johnson, trade and industry secretary, will lead the talks with Allan Leighton, Royal Mail chairman.

Read More

Romanian Delivery Services Market At 42.75 Mln Euro in 2005

The Romanian market for courier and international delivery services is expected to grow to USD50 mln (42.75 mln euro) in 2005, up from USD38.5 mln (32.9 mln euro) in 2004, it was reported on December 28, 2005. TNT Romania, the local subsidiary of Dutch TNT Express, and DHL Romania, the local unit of US delivery company DHL, held 80 pct of the market in 2004, followed by Trans Couriers Service, an authorised representative of U.S. delivery company UPS.

Read More




P&P Poll


What’s the future of the postal USO?

Thank you for voting
You have already voted on this poll!
Please select an option!

MER Magazine

The Mail & Express Review (MER) Magazine is our quarterly print publication. Packed with original content and thought-provoking features, MER is a must-read for those who want the inside track on the industry.


News Archive

Pin It on Pinterest